The voting for X-Mormon of the Year is underway you have until January 20th to get your vote in!!
As usual, we’re also doing the Brodie Awards — a fun little yearly activity intended to give some extra recognition and signal boost to the best LDS-interest content published/posted during the past year.
Unfortunately, this has been a bit of a slow year so far for the Brodie awards — in part because I haven’t had as much time to keep things lively here at MSP since taking my new job. I’m glad to see some people are still having fun with this and have started leaving their nominations!
Now I’m going to do a first-pass of organizing this year’s categories, adding some nominations of my own, and pointing out which categories need more nominations. Remember that each category needs a least three nominations to continue on to the voting and awards rounds. The nomination process will continue for two more weeks and then we will begin voting. Here we go!
Year-long awards for people and groups:
Best New Blog/Channel/Podcast
- My Mormon Experience by Ethan Dodge
- No Man Knows My Herstory
- My Story to Write
- Radio Free Mormon
- Brandon’s Travel Tips
Best Humor/Satire Blog/Channel/Podcast
Best Mormon History Blog/Channel/Podcast
- Naked Mormonism
- This category needs more nominations.
Best LDS-Church-Info Site
Best LDS-interest Discussion Forum
- Thoughtful Transitions FB group
- Millennial Mormonism FB group
- r/mormon
- r/exmormon
Best Exmormon Reddit Contributor
- u/invisibles_cubit
- u/relevantlife
- This category needs more nominations.
Best faithful-perspective Mormon Blog
- Tocubit is Invisible’s Cubit, by Sam Young
- This category needs more nominations.
Awards for Individual Works:
Best LDS-Interest Book (Fiction)
- Through his Eyes and Lies, by C. L. Jackson
- The Book of Laman, by Mette Ivie Harrison
- Behind the Bishop’s Door, by Johnny Townsend
Best LDS-Interest Book (General non-fiction)
- Michael Quinn’s Mormon Hierarchy: wealth and corporate power
- This category needs more nominations.
Best LDS-Interest Book (Narrative non-fiction)
- Truth in Reason, by Nikolas Rex
- You’re Not Alone: Exit Journeys of Former Mormons, by Jessica Bradshaw
- This category needs more nominations.
Best LDS-Interest Song
- Tapirback Rider, by Weird Alma
- This category needs more nominations.
Best Poem
- “My friend’s poem” (Anonymous)
- This category needs more nominations.
Best LDS-Interest Comic or Image
Best Mormon-Themed Meme
- Mormonism is anti-me, by Missed In Sunday
- This category needs more nominations.
Best Post Title
- Rocky Mountain Low, by Jack Naneek
- How to Fix Your Sunday School Class Using These Three Easy Tricks, by Stephen Carter
- Out of the Frying Pan of a Closet and Into the Fire: Bobby Flay Made My Cousin Gay!*, by AlexisAR
Funniest Humor Piece
- Mormons name their kids the darnedest things: Born in 2016 edition, by Jessie Jensen
- Evil Apostate Series, by Thoughts on Things and Stuff
- God Steps Down Amid Sexual Assault Allegations, by Tanner Gilliland
Funniest Parody
- Infant General Conference – Oct 2017
- New Gospel Topics Essay, by Moss
- “MR. HERBERT, TEAR DOWN THIS CURTAIN!” PROCLAIMS AN EMBOLDENED SENATOR DABAKIS
- Straight Outta Cumorah, by Weird Alma
Best Metaphor/Analogy/Allegory
- Parable of the Prodigal Daughter, by Chiaroscuro
- Mormon McDonald’s: An Allegory, by Gina Colvin
- This category needs more nominations.
Best From the Pulpit Sermon
- Savannah’s Testimony
- This category needs more nominations.
Most Poignant Personal Story
- The Mexican Kids in the Trash Pile, by Dan Pearce
- “Cabaret” and a Confused Teenage Boy, by Joseph Broom
- My Sorrow, by Brooke W
- Dear Elder Oaks, by Blaire Ostler
- Mike Norton on Mormon Stories
Best Exit Story
- Breaking the Silence, by Royleane Otteson
- Moving On, by Bethany Jane
- The view from inside the bubble, by Heather B. Armstrong
- On Mormonism, authenticity, and spiritual epiphanies in Sin City, by the Narrator
Best Life Journey Piece
- Stepping Out of the Big Tent: The Possibility of Leaving Mormonism, by Lynette
- Inoculation and Echo Chambers, by Andrew S
- “You Lost Me”, by hawkgrrrl
- Leaving, by Tracy M.
- A quarter of a century ago, by Jana Remy
- I Will Not Go Back in the Closet, by Ben
- Pioneers, by Myrtlejoy
- What should an Active Mormon consider when encountering ex-Mormons or anti-Mormon sites/literature? by Dan Deceuster
Best Activist Movement Within Mormonism
- Protect the Children Petition by Sam Young
- Ordain Women
- Free BYU
Best Leak or Personal Recording
- Anonymous via MormonLeaks GA pay information
- Anonymous via MormonLeaks PowerPoint “Enemies List”
- Savannah’s Testimony originally released by NewNameNoah
- Trevor Haugen recording with Don Clark (Q70) and Matt Growe (church historian), originally released on Mormon Stories Podcast
Best LDS Church Watch Piece
- Fact vs. Fiction: Pioneer John Rowe Moyle and His Wooden Leg, by Mary Ann
- I Can’t Unsee It, by Leah Marie
- Did Joy D. Jones really just use the words “Mother in Heaven” in a General Conference session?, by Libby
- Eclipsing the Truth, by Alex
- Happy 12th Birthday! Now, Let Me Ask…. by Sam Young
Best Response to Apologetics
- Five Myths about Mormons and Money, by Mormonism 101
- Correlation Kettle Meet Snuffer Pot, by Mogget
- Problematic Apologetics: A Response to the “Lengthening Shadow” Interpreter Article, by Mary Ann
- The Boy Who Cried Religious Freedom, by Sam Brunson
- Response to 3Mormons on Race in Mormonism, by Thoughts on Things and Stuff
- Lamanite DNA, by The Mormon Informant
- Commentary: The gaslighting within Mormonism must stop, by Ryan McKnight and Ethan Dodge
- Zelph on the Shelf responds to the article “Alarming Truth Behind Anti Mormons”
Best LDS-Culture Piece
- The Ignorance of Defensive Mormons, by Donna Banta
- Caffeine and the Hedge around the Law, by Michael Austin
- Being esteemed as filthiness: What Not to Wear, by Rebecca J
- A Thought about Faith-promoting Stories, by Ziff
- Practical Apologetics: What’s Wrong With You? by Dave Banack
- The Mormon temple wedding photo game, by Mette Harrison
- I have a porn problem, by the Mighty Tapir
- Surviving Sacrament Meeting, by Terresa Wellborn
- Great Expectations, by Myrtlejoy
- 178 & 179: The Truths About Marital Intimacy: A Critique of Wendy Nelson’s Sex Talk: Helfer-Parker and de Azevedo-Hanks
Best History Piece
- How Jesus Christ Was Ousted As Head Of The Church of Jesus Christ, by Alan Rock Waterman
- Origin of the Baptism for the Dead Doctrine, by grindæl
- Coffee, by Kevin Barney
Best Scripture Study Piece
- Ether 15: The End of the World As We Know It, by Alex
- The Isaiah Nephi Could Not Have Known: A Response to Dr. Kent Jackson, by Yakov Ben Tov
- The BoM and the Aeneid, by Kevin Barney
- The Day They Came, by Morgan Deane
- Grab that Rod of Iron! by Adult Onset Atheist
Best Discussion on Parenting
- Taking Back My Power, by Dad’s Primal Scream
- This category needs more nominations.
Best Discussion on Orientation
- Forced to Look at Our Straight Privilege, by Natasha Helfer Parker
- White Shirt, Black Name Tag, Big Secret, by Ellis Jeter
- This category needs more nominations.
Best Discussion on Gender
- The Inadvertent Objectification of Women in the Church, by Amber Haslam
- Who wants your old boys’ club, anyway? by Libby
- Cheating LDS Young Women – Again, by Gina Colvin
- Q&A: Why aren’t Mormon feminists thrilled with the new LDS temple baptistry policy? by April Young Bennett
- Modesty as a Matter of Life and Death, by Mormon Heretic
- If Gender is Essential, Why Are We Pushing It?, by hawkgrrrl
- John Dehlin and the women problem, by DearJohnDehlin
- I am not a Mother, by Petra
- Evangelical Notions About Women, by Andrew Hackman
Best Discussion on Race
- The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-Day Racism, by Sam Young
- Eliminating Any Lingering Disapproval Of Interracial Marriage, by Carolyn
- Facing our Racial History, by Jason L
- Racism in the Book of Mormon — Yep, it’s there, by Miguel Barker-Valdez
- The Excommunication of Ayla Stewart, by Adult Onset Atheist
- We’re Losing Our Racial Purity!, by AlexisAR
Most Insightful Commentary on the CoJCoL-dS
- A Post-Mormon Documents some Recent Positive Changes in Mormonism, by William Kempton
- Responsible FAP, by Adult Onset Atheist
- What Does the CoJCoL-dS Offer? by chanson
- It is a Festivus for the rest of us… by David Johnson
- Credit, Blame, and the Influence of the Church, by Lynette
Best Philosophical/Theological Discussion
- Fasting for God… by Knotty
- God Didn’t Do This To Me. by Brooke W
- The Theology of the Proclamation, by Thomas Montgomery
- What’s a Prophet For, Anyway?, by Samantha Shelley
- What we know about Heavenly Mother, by Dani Addante
- the LDS Doctrine of families being “together forever.” by Cinepro
Best short media presentation
- Bryce Blankenagel and Cody Noconi, Sunstone Symposium, Revelation Through Hallucination
- This category needs more nominations.
Best Book Review
- Knotty’s review of “The Gate and The Garden: The Apostate Journals of a Gay Mormon Missionary in Japan”
- Inside the mind of the Book of Mormon’s first antagonist, by David Evans
- Alliegator’s review of “That We May Be One: A Gay Mormon’s Perspective on Faith & Family”
- A Truth Universally Acknowledged: Two LDS Romance Reviews, by Donna Banta
- 6 Must-Read Books for Ex-Mormons, by Samantha Shelley
- Introducing Singing and Dancing to the Book of Mormon: Critical Essays on the Broadway Musical, by Jerry Argetsinger
- Nancy Hales review of the Garden of Enid
How to nominate: Just post your nominations as comment to this thread, but please include links to the works you nominate. If your nomination comment ends up in the spam filter, please email me (chanson dot exmormon at gmail dot com) and I will fish it out. (Also note that if you post each nomination as a separate comment, they’re less likely to get flagged as spam.)
And don’t forget the nomination guidelines:
- Please nominate as many people, books, blogs, sites, podcasts, songs, articles, images, etc. as you want. However, please do not nominate more than two individual works by any one author/artist.
- You are encouraged to nominate your own works. No one knows better than you do which pieces were your best. No more than two, though.
- Please nominate works that first appeared during 2017.
- Please try to nominate people and works that have some connection with Mormonism (eg. either the work touches on Mormonism, or the author is a current or former Mormon and/or is an active participant in our community).
- A category must have at least three nominations in order to be included in the voting and awards phase.
- You may suggest your own categories — however please do it as early as possible in the nominations process, to give others plenty of time to add nominations in your proposed categories.
- Any other proposed changes to the categories or to the guidelines are welcome — feel free to discuss it in the comments.
- The nominations will be open until mid-January, 2018, depending on my schedule. I will finalize the dates and categories and add my own nominations a few days before the nominations close and voting begins.
Thanks for all of your nominations!!!
Best new podcast of 2017, Mormon Happy Hour. Angelsonfire.org
Best Short Media Presentation
MormonLeaks – Transparency and Ethics in the 21st Century, Ryan McKnight
https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=DUz4SK4ZD1M
Best Mormon History Podcast : Year of Polygamy http://www.yearofpolygamy.com
Clarence Tong wrote a poem as an answer to the Ensign artcle from April 2017 called, The War Goes On
We had a friend put it onto a reinbow background and it made the rounds for several months
I just published it on a website so that I an nominate Clarence Tong’s for his poetry. Thank you
Pat Bagley, perfect juxtaposition: Anything Presidential to confess.
Best Short Media Presentation: Donovan Feist’s remarks at the resignation rally in Salt Lake City in November>by Donovan Feist.
Best Life Journey Piece: A Sunday in the life of a closeted exmormon by Reddit user my_name_is_NO
Best from-the-pulpit sermon: Three Sisters by Dieter Uchtdorf
Best Discussion on Orientation: McMurrin Lecture: Science vs. Dogma by Gregory Prince
Best from-the-pulpit Sermon: Act of Confession by Reverend Jerrod Lowry (in unison with the assembled pastorate) at the Utah Pride Interfaith Service in Salt Lake City on June 1.
Best Podcast Episode: Steve Shields by Project Zion Podcast, Josh Mangelson interviewer
Please, check the spam filter for a post with four nominations.
I nominate /r/MormonDoctrine for Best LDS interest discussion forum
Best Exmormon Reddit Contributor
/u/Chino_Blanco
Best History Piece
Gileriodekel’s “Undeniable proof that the Journal of Discourses (JoD) was/is an official church publication.” https://redd.it/6et1mn
(I know its cheesy to nominate yourself, but JoD is very often dismissed as not an official publication, and I haven’t seen a response to that line of thought as thorough as mine.)
Best Philosophical/Theological Discussion
/u/PedanticGod’s /r/MormonDoctrine
Thanks for all the great nominations, everyone!!
Keep ’em coming! 😀
@4blockhead — I looked in the spam filter, but I can’t find the comment. Can you try again to post them in individual comments? Or just email them to me (chanson dot exmormon at gmail dot com), and I will post them myself as nominations from you.
Thanks, and sorry for the inconvenience.
Best Discussion on Parenting:
“The F-Word that Really Harms Our Kids” @BrynneGant https://medium.com/@brynnetg/the-f-word-that-really-harms-our-kids-3a6a6993b567
Best LDS-Culture Piece:
“They Can Leave the Church, But They Can’t Leave the Church Alone” @BrynneGant https://medium.com/@brynnetg/they-can-leave-the-church-but-they-cant-leave-the-church-alone-298cc12d399
Best Response to Apologetics:
“They Can Leave the Church, But They Can’t Leave the Church Alone” @BrynneGant https://medium.com/@brynnetg/they-can-leave-the-church-but-they-cant-leave-the-church-alone-298cc12d399
Funniest humor piece:
https://medium.com/@ryanmcknight_61338/letter-from-mormon-missionary-puts-the-recent-push-for-more-transparency-on-display-6dfd0fd31092
(Ryan McKnight)
Best Response to Apologetics: Debunking uniqueness of NHM on the Arabian peninsulaby Reddit user KenjaTime_
Best Exit Story: an email to her bishop rejects any and all callings because representing the church in any capacity would compromise her integrity. by Reddit user PlanitL
Best Podcast Episode: Year of Polygamy, Episode 139, Dispelling the idea that Joseph Smith fought polygamy by Lindsay Hansen Park with John Dinger, Bryan Buchanan, and John Hatch
Best History Piece: How ideas in the Book of Mormon parallel ideas from the nineteenth century by Reddit user bwv549
Best Comic or Image: house of cards by Reddit user 4blockhead
Best Exmormon Contributor: missedinsunday
Best Podcast Episode: Who is Denver Snuffer? by Bill McKeever and Eric Johnson, Mormonism Research Ministry
Best Short Media Presentation: commentary on BBC’s 2012 interview with apostle Jeffrey Holland by Reddit user bomonomo, blogger “Thinker of Thoughts” (commentary was finally allowed under fair use in 2017)
Best History Piece: an Official LDS essay relies on an interesting historical article from 1831 by Reddit user anyonehaveanswers
Best Discussion on ParentingNew Order Mormons, do you enforce that your children attend church, and only at the Brighamite ward? by Reddit user 4blockhead
Best Metaphor/Analogy/Allegory: The Church used my body as currency by Reddit user sarahpratt
Thanks for all of the great nominations!!! I was so disappointed that this was going to be a slow year, but you guys are really coming through! 😀
Please nominate this for Best Poem!
http://thewar-goes-on.com/
Best Discussion on Parenting: Advice about sex for a college-bound girl by Gabrielle Blair
Best Podcast Episode: at the Salt Lake City Public Library, Peggy Fletcher Stack reflects on 26 Years on the Faith BeatMormon Land, Jennifer Napier-Pearce interviewer.
Best short media presentation: Zelph on the Shelf, “Reading Greg Trimble: You Should Not Leave Mormonism For Any Of These 5 Reasons.”
http://zelphontheshelf.com/reading-greg-trimble-you-should-not-leave-mormonism-for-any-of-these-5-reasons-video/
Best short media presentation: Way of the Mister: Steel Swords and Burning Bosoms by Brian Dalton
Nominating Deb Diener of Children Matter FB Page who compiled a huge list of instances of Child Sexual Abuse perpetrated by LDS members. This was a ton of work and she deserves to be recognized for working so hard to protect the children.
I’m not sure what catagory but please add her or make one and get more women on your list!
Best Scripture Study Piece: Viewpoint on Mormonism: The Book of Galatians by Mormonism Research Ministry, Bill McKeever and Eric Johnson
Best LDS commentary/watch peiece!
http://thoughtsonthingsandstuff.com/face2face-about-prayer/
This is amazing and doesn’t get the notice it should. Hear two apostles admit that they rarely get answers from prayer and that we need to prepare to approach the throne of God to pray and that he isn’t going to respond to trivial things or even respond at all. So basically the brethren are winging it.
Great Job Jonathan.
Best Mormon History Blog/Channel/Site
Thoughts on Things and Stuff
Best Discussion on Race
“Response to 3 Mormons on Race” https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2c6gY7QfT8k&t=921s
Best Short Media Presentation (? Not sure if it fits)
Henry Eyring – Masterclass in Emotional Manipulation https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dcdqj37fbWo&t=440s
Best song:
Mother where art thou, by Julie de Azevedo. https://store.cdbaby.com/cd/juliedeazevedo
Best Exmormon Reddit Contributor /u/bwv549. (Comment history speaks for itself. The depth and breadth and quality of his contributions are especially deserving of a Brodie nomination and our votes. He’s charitable in every conversation and his insights have elevated the discussion more than any other Redditor discussing Mormonism at the moment. It’s a pleasure to make this nomination.)
Best Podcast Episode Mormon Discussions: The Backdrop and Context of The Family A Proclamation to the World
http://www.mormondiscussionpodcast.org/2017/10/special-episode-backdrop-context-family-proclamation-world/
Best commentary/response to Church Event
Face2Face series, Thinker of Thoughts
https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLevx2DAlF-YBVWwRmN1pYn-6NiwonAaju
Best new website – missed in Sunday school
http://www.missedinsunday.com
Craig Stapley
Best humor/parody
Weird Alma
http://www.weirdalma.com
This fabric of yours is truly worth typically the time
I’ve spent reading it. Typically the last time I have seen something nearly as good was
with https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.essaypro.devellux. I would just like to thank you for a
new job well done. Keep writing, you are effective in it!