Skip to content
Main Street Plaza

A Community for Anyone Interested in Mormonism.

Main Street Plaza

A Community for Anyone Interested in Mormonism.

Power and Morality

Hellmut, October 26, 2008October 26, 2008

The Jesuit magazine America features an essay by Cathleen Kaveny, which discusses the concept of inherent evil and it’s political implications. This passage caught my attention:

Some Catholic commentators have claimed that the certainty we have about the wrongfulness of intrinsically evil acts means that we should give their prevention priority over other acts, which may or may not be wrong, depending upon the circumstances. Their argument seems to run like this: the church teaches that abortion, euthanasia and homosexual acts are always wrong, but not that war or capital punishment is always wrong. Therefore, good Catholics ought to focus their political efforts on preventing acts they know to be wrong, and remain agnostic about the rest. One commentator has suggested that the church gives us “wiggle room” on issues that do not involve intrinsically evil acts.

If abortion and homosexuality are intrinsically wrong but war and capital punishment are not always wrong then one need not be a cynic to notice that power is enmeshed into the definition of intrinsically evil. Compared to the rulers who have to decide about war and peace and who have people executed, gays and pregnant women are relatively powerless.

Theologians and church leaders that accuse rulers of being evil may very well be held accountable, especially when the thinkers are insensitive to the exigencies of life. By contrast, a raped woman rarely has the capacity to hold church leaders accountable.

The notable exception is, of course, euthanasia. Confronting the Nazis for poisoning mentally disabled children, Bishop Count Galen risked his life. Since heroes are rare, however, belief systems are unlikely to be systematically grounded in heroics, which would control for various levels of power.

It’s probably no accident that there is “wiggle room” for war but not for homosexuality but a consequence of the fact that the typical ruler is much more powerful than gays.

I do not think that Catholic theology is purposefully insensitive to the exigencies of less powerful people. It is just that accountability focuses the mind. Power generates incentives that certain problems get more attention than others.

Short of coercion, it might actually be a good thing when thinkers have to answer for their knowledge claims. Considering a problem more carefully by taking people’s exigencies into account and will improve moral philosophy. Insofar as the distribution of power is inherently connected to certain kind of ethical questions, we have to expect that the quality of ethical philosophy and theology will be uneven because some problems are not inherently associated with powerful actors.

It follows that we ought to remain skeptical, humble, and suspicious with regard to human knowledge claims, especially, when we are dealing in absolutes.

I found the essay thanks to Andrew Sullivan.

Ethics Objectivity Philosophy Power Theology

Post navigation

Previous post
Next post

Related Posts

We Were Asking for It

November 3, 2008November 3, 2008

If you sew the wind, you shall reap the storm. If you live by the sword, you shall die by the sword. It’s just sad.

Read More

Sunday in Outer Blogness: What do Mormons believe? edition!

March 27, 2011November 9, 2011

First and foremost — Outer Blogness has gotten a major technical upgrade!!! This is such a huge and vibrant community that it deserves its own page where you can get a clear view of what’s up. It also means faster loading of our main page and more space in our…

Read More

Your Sunday School Lesson: The First Vision

January 13, 2009January 15, 2011

According to the philosopher Mircea Eliade, of whose work I learned at BYU, every community, tribe, or nation requires an origin myth. The account of a community’s or practice’s origin has far reaching consequences because it implies how they relate to the cosmos, which is necessary for human beings to…

Read More

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Mormon Alumni Association Books

Latest Comments:

  1. Cara B. Klein on My conspiracy theory #2April 26, 2025

    Wow, I had never thought about it in that way before You have really opened my eyes to a new…

  2. chanson on LDS vs LGBTQ:  Nathan Kitchen sheds false binariesApril 16, 2025

    The haiku at the end is lovely. Sounds like a great book!

  3. Donna Banta on LDS vs LGBTQ:  Nathan Kitchen sheds false binariesApril 14, 2025

    I imagine anyone who has tried to change the church from within will identify with Kitchen's story. I especially like…

  4. Johnny Townsend on LDS vs LGBTQ:  Nathan Kitchen sheds false binariesApril 14, 2025

    This was a painful review to read. For many years, I held the same hope, that the LDS church would…

  5. LDS vs LGBTQ:  Nathan Kitchen sheds false binaries – Main Street Plaza on It’s Time to Vote for the 2024 Brodie Awards!!!April 14, 2025

    […] sincere acceptance is not a priority. Fortunately, this is what he exemplifies in his memoir, the Brodie-nominated Boughs of…

8: The Mormon Proposition Acceptance of Gays Add new tag Affirmation angry exmormon awards Book Reviews BYU comments Conformity Dallin H. Oaks DAMU disaffected mormon underground Dustin Lance Black Ex-Mormon Exclusion policy Excommunicated exmormon faith Family feminism Gay Gay Love Gay Marriage Gay Relationships General Conference Happiness Homosexual Homosexuality LDS LGBT LGBTQ Link Bomb missionaries Modesty Mormon Mormon Alumni Association Mormonism motherhood peace politics Polygamy priesthood ban Sunstone temple

Awards

William Law X-Mormon of the Year:

  • 2023: Adam Steed
  • 2022: David Archuleta
  • 2021: Jeff T. Green
  • 2020: Jacinda Ardern
  • 2019: David Nielsen
  • 2018: Sam Young
  • 2017: Savannah
  • 2016: Jeremy Runnells
  • 2015: John Dehlin
  • 2014: Kate Kelly
  • 2013: J. Seth Anderson and Michael Ferguson
  • 2012: David Tweede
  • 2011: Joanna Brooks
  • 2010: Monica Bielanko
  • 2009: Walter Kirn

Other Cool Sites!

WasMormon.org
©2025 Main Street Plaza | WordPress Theme by SuperbThemes