Skip to content
Main Street Plaza

A Community for Anyone Interested in Mormonism.

Main Street Plaza

A Community for Anyone Interested in Mormonism.

A Review of September Dawn

JohnHamer, June 17, 2007October 20, 2010

I saw an advance screening of the much anticipated September Dawn on Wednesday night. I’ve spent the week at the Kirtland Temple and the local theater invited all the staff here to a free screening. (I wonder if they issued a similar invitation to the LDS Mormons down on the flats in the LDS Historic Kirtland area… If so, I’m pretty sure that none of them showed up.)

For those not already aware, September Dawn is the new Dain Cain film about the Mountain Meadows Massacre. You can see the trailer for it here: http://www.septemberdawn.net/

If you don’t want to color your impressions prior to watching this thing, come back to this review after you’ve seen it.

*

*

*

I have to say that I didn’t like the movie. I spent too much time cringing at what the people were saying to get into it. The big quotes said by Brigham Young and Joseph Smith, including BY’s famous blood atonement discourse and JS’s “Alcoran or the Sword” quote (attested in an affidavit by Thomas B. Marsh were real quotes. However, the crazy things that individual fictional characters in the movie were saying, e.g. “I will do my duty to the Mormon God Brigham Young” were a mess.

In the end, I don’t think that either society was portrayed realistically. The Fancher party seems to have been using immigration to California as an excuse to hold constant Protestant church services — they have about 5 before they are finally wiped out. In one, the benevolent prayer of the Protestant minister (the father of the female love interest) is contrasted directly with the sinister malevolent prayer of the Mormon bishop (the father of the male love interest). Whereas I agree that the Fanchers were innocent victims of the Mormons, I don’t know that they were a pack of traveling monks.

The portrayal of Mormon society is worse. The Mormons are seen as long established in Utah, with well developed farms, towns, tabernacles and even temples. In one scene, after the Fancher party is already at Mountain Meadows, the bishop takes the male lead to “the temple” to have his endowments. Of course, no Mormon temple existed west of Lyman Wight’s temple in Zodiac, Texas. The only place that Brighamites were having endowments done was the Endowment House in SLC. The distance between Cedar City and Salt Lake City is thus ignored — which also muddies the situation of Brigham Young’s involvement in the massacre. In the movie, the Fancher party is already camped at Mountain Meadows when Brigham Young orders their destruction. That error (along with other carelessness) is a get out of jail free card for people who may want to defend BY against the charges made in the movie.

In the end, on the Braveheart scale of historical accuracy, this thing as a whole is more accurate than Gladiator (whose score of “0” is approximately the same as Pirates of the Caribbean’s rating). It’s probably also better than Braveheart’s score of 1. It’s probably more like Titanic’s score of 2.

Cross-posted here. 

Community of Christ Culture LDS History Polygamy

Post navigation

Previous post
Next post

Related Posts

Atheists and Traditions

November 27, 2009

Religion has a lot different facets that different people find appealing: identity/community transcendence/awe/altered states of consciousness rituals tradition/culture purpose/guidance belief in the supernatural And surely many others. It’s my impression that people tend to focus on a few of their favorites among these components and ignore the rest. It’s just…

Read More

A Secular Family Easter!!!

April 8, 2007October 20, 2010

Who’d have thought a religious holiday would be so conducive to learning about science?? But we learned by experiment last year that leaving eggs in a water-and-vinegar solution degrades the shells, and we applied that knowledge to do a better job on our egg-coloring adventure this year!!!

Read More

The Nature of Sexuality

March 26, 2009June 15, 2023

Todd just found a youtube video of the documentary Legacies about the treatment of Mormon gays by their church: Spencer Kimball’s attitudes about sexuality, unfortunately, can only be characterized as superstition. In the Mormon case, superstition is intertwined with claims to personal revelation. The latter is defined such that the…

Read More

Comments (6)

  1. exmoron says:
    June 18, 2007 at 9:08 am

    Thanks for the review. I’ve been wondering if it is going to be any good. You answered that. It’s a shame that potentially revealing films about Mormonism spend so much time on things that just aren’t true when the truth is so shocking it doesn’t actually need embellishment.

  2. Demon of Kolob says:
    June 18, 2007 at 9:24 am

    The movie is by Christopher Cain. Dean Cain is his actor son who plays Joseph Smith in the movie.

  3. theMormonator says:
    June 19, 2007 at 3:36 pm

    I went to the same screening and LOVED IT!!!!!!!!!

    I have to diagree with John. I think he needs to read up on this true event in history. Although it is not a pleasant depiction of what happened, it seems to be pretty accurate as deemed by several Mormon historians.

    Although I am not much for “Love Stories,” that aspect didn’t bother me that much. I thought the chemistry was great between the two young actors.

    I do have to say that my only real complaint is that the violence, although on the border of being unbearable in this film, was artistically portrayed compared to the actual historical death of this innocent wagon train. In reality, children’s heads were beaten in with rocks and they were stripped naked to be eaten by animals.

    I feel it is an important film worth seeing and beautifully crafted.

    The official website offers some educational links to check out for yourself:

    http://www.SeptemberDawn.net

    I would suggest drawing your own conclusion…But I thought this was a great movie with a great musical score… much better than Braveheart!

  4. JohnHamer says:
    June 19, 2007 at 8:50 pm

    Demon, you’re right — I accidently colluded Christopher Cain and Dean Cain in my head. However, the one was the director, the other is an actor.

  5. Zelph says:
    June 20, 2007 at 10:02 pm

    Interestingly enough, Richard Dutcher defends the film, saying that it is told from the point of view of the Fancher party, which point of view rarely ever gets told. I think that is an interesting and well taken point. The film isn’t balanced itself, but it is more of a balance to all the white-washed versions in a way. However, from everything I have heard, it sounds like it will be a pretty bad movie.

  6. theMormonator says:
    July 2, 2007 at 10:09 pm

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Mormon Alumni Association Books

Latest Comments:

  1. termal kamerayla su kaçak tespiti on LDS vs LGBTQ:  Nathan Kitchen sheds false binariesJune 21, 2025

    termal kamerayla su kaçak tespiti Ekip çok organize, kaça?? an?nda bulup çözdüler. https://bence.net/read-blog/25188

  2. Cara B. Klein on My conspiracy theory #2April 26, 2025

    Wow, I had never thought about it in that way before You have really opened my eyes to a new…

  3. chanson on LDS vs LGBTQ:  Nathan Kitchen sheds false binariesApril 16, 2025

    The haiku at the end is lovely. Sounds like a great book!

  4. Donna Banta on LDS vs LGBTQ:  Nathan Kitchen sheds false binariesApril 14, 2025

    I imagine anyone who has tried to change the church from within will identify with Kitchen's story. I especially like…

  5. Johnny Townsend on LDS vs LGBTQ:  Nathan Kitchen sheds false binariesApril 14, 2025

    This was a painful review to read. For many years, I held the same hope, that the LDS church would…

8: The Mormon Proposition Acceptance of Gays Add new tag Affirmation angry exmormon awards Book Reviews BYU comments Conformity Dallin H. Oaks DAMU disaffected mormon underground Dustin Lance Black Ex-Mormon Exclusion policy Excommunicated exmormon faith Family feminism Gay Gay Love Gay Marriage Gay Relationships General Conference Happiness Homosexual Homosexuality LDS LGBT LGBTQ Link Bomb missionaries Modesty Mormon Mormon Alumni Association Mormonism motherhood peace politics Polygamy priesthood ban Sunstone temple

Awards

William Law X-Mormon of the Year:

  • 2023: Adam Steed
  • 2022: David Archuleta
  • 2021: Jeff T. Green
  • 2020: Jacinda Ardern
  • 2019: David Nielsen
  • 2018: Sam Young
  • 2017: Savannah
  • 2016: Jeremy Runnells
  • 2015: John Dehlin
  • 2014: Kate Kelly
  • 2013: J. Seth Anderson and Michael Ferguson
  • 2012: David Tweede
  • 2011: Joanna Brooks
  • 2010: Monica Bielanko
  • 2009: Walter Kirn

Other Cool Sites!

WasMormon.org
©2025 Main Street Plaza | WordPress Theme by SuperbThemes