Collecting Nominations for the 2010 Brodies!!!
Yes, it’s that time of year again!! Time to recognize the best LDS-interest sites and material posted to the Internet in the past year!!! Look here for last year’s winners — and if you didn’t win last year, this year it could be you!! (Actually, even if you did win last year, you might win again.)
Now, I’d like to start off with a list of suggested categories. This is to simplify the nomination process, but you can also write in new categories if you think I’ve missed any. To be included in the voting, a category must have at least three nominations total (and at least two people must submit nominations for the category). Like last year, it is OK to nominate your own site/post, but please, only suggest categories people would want to win (eg. no “biggest jerk”, etc.). Here we go!
- Best LDS-Interest Site on the Internet
- Best New Blog
- Best Discussion Forum
- Best Static Site on LDS Issues
- Best YouTube Channel
- Best Individual Video
- Best LDS-Interest Podcast
- Best Faithful Mormon Blog
- Best Humor Site
- Most Humorous Post
- Best Philosophical/Religious Post
- Best Political Post
- Best LDS Church Watch
- Best Intrepid Reporting
- Best “Life Beyond Mormonism” Post
- Best Deconversion/Exit Story
- Most Poignant Personal Story
- Best Bridge-Building
- Best Book Review
- Best Response to Apologetics
- Best Post Title
- Best Gender/Orientation Discussion
- Randomest Threadjack
- Best Comment
- Other ideas?
ETA:
- Best Blog
- Best Historical Post
- Best Science Post
I can’t wait to see what you all come up with!!! 😀
For best discussion board, I would nominate exmormon.reddit.com, postmormon.org, and exmormon.org (because I want to see them lose, of course).
Shall we also nominate the reddit for best (overall) site?
Note: I forgot to include “Best Blog” — consider it added.
Also, “Best Historical post” and “Best Science Post”.
I’m going to nominate a post from reddit’s “CelestialBound” for Best post and Best exit story:
http://www.reddit.com/r/exmormon/comments/d2yqz/my_review_of_my_disciplinary_council_where_i_got/
CB gives a full accounting of an excommunication.
Wow!! Great story to open the nominations with!
I nominate i-am-an-exmormon.com for best LDS interest site and best new blog 🙂
And I nominate Flackerman for best youtube channel, he HAS to win for something I love his channel:
http://www.youtube.com/user/FlackerMan
I second the nomination for i-am-an-exmormon.com
For best response to apologetics, I nominate Why I Won’t Leave the Mormon Church Alone, a brilliant response by Holly Welker to Boyd Packer’s condescending ridicule that we “can leave the Church but they can’t leave the Church alone.”
I second the nomination of exmormon.reddit.com
I’ll second this one as well: i-am-an-exmormon.com for best LDS interest site and best new blog
How about “best explanation of Mo theology for outsiders” and “strangest Mo situation/phenomenon”?
I’d suggest also voting on “Best Mormon Expression episode” … and here are my nominees:
Episode 44: An Interview with Zilpha
Episode 51: Interview with Will Bagley (Part 1 & Part 2)
Episode 76: Mistakes were Made: How not to Leave the Church
Suggested new category: “Best r/exmo link o’ the year”
Nominees:
Mormon comic submitted to FFFFUUUUUUUUUUU really hits home.
Just finished making this masterpiece, I’m pretty proud of it!
I just found this hurtful letter from my dad. He wrote it to me when he found out I left the church.
Corporatism is the foundation of the LDS church.
My review of my disciplinary council where I got x’d on August 18th, 2010.
Victory Over Mormonism, and over bigotry! Prop 8 ruled unconstitutional!
What I wore to church today…
“Came out” to my wife last night
Freedom
Baptism Convo with an 8 year old…
I’m not sure where it belongs, but I want to see this site get nominated for something, dammit: Mormon Correlation Studies
And Christopher Kimball Bigelow’s “Letter to President Packer” deserves a prize.
Off the top of my head I would nominate Prof Bill Bradshaw for the “Best Bridge Building”. I will have to think of some others!
Most Humorous Rant: Lying for the Lord
Best New Gay Mormon Blog: Invictus Pilgrim
I want to nominate ProfXM’s post here at MSP: Will this hateful rhetoric continue once Boyd K. Packer has passed on? … maybe file under “Best LDS Church Watch” ?
One thing is for sure, Chino and Prof, Boyd Packer will become the most manly among the prophets, seers, and revelators.
I nominate Boyd Packer’s conference address as the best bridge building effort ever because no one has driven more traffic to MSP than that man.
Great suggestions!!
Looking at #13, I think we should probably have a “Best Comic or LOL DAMUZ”.
Regarding podcasts @12, it seems reasonable to have a “Best Podcast Series” (eg. Mormon Expression vs. Mormon Stories) and a separate category for best individual episode.
For Best Deconversion/Exit Story and/or Best Response to Apologetics (I’m not really sure where it fits better): How Star Wars destroyed my faith in God.
I agree that that post by Chris Bigelow deserves a prize. perhaps “Best illustration of Poe’s Law”?
I nominate that anything Christopher Bigelow writes is the Best Illustration of Poe’s Law!
Some great nominations so far. I especially like Holly Welker’s piece (which I’ve read again and again call it “Why I Won’t Leave Holly Welker Alone”). And I’m glad to see Dr. Bradshaw mentioned.
I nominate this one for Best Humor Site: http://wardgossip.blogspot.com/
Best Response to apologetics:
http://chriscarrollsmith.blogspot.com/2010/08/let-papyrus-length-calculation-wars.html
url=http://chriscarrollsmith.blogspot.com/2010/07/is-book-of-abraham-papyrus-missing.html]Is the Book of Abraham Papyrus “Missing”?
Best Philosophical/Religious Post:
http://www.clobberblog.com/?p=4058#more-4058
Best Bridge Building Blog:
http://www.clobberblog.com/
http://thefaithfuldissident.blogspot.com/
Best Faithful Mormon Blog:
http://www.lifeongoldplates.com/
http://davidbokovoy.com/
Best Historical Post:
http://josephantley.com/2010/10/22/early-american-treasure-seeking-rituals-topical-guide-updated/
Best Gender/Orientation Discussion:
http://www.sethpayne.com/?p=967#more-967
Most Humorous Post:
http://runtu.wordpress.com/2010/12/19/christmas-repost-evidence-trending-in-frostys-direction-farms-says/
Here are my nominations:
Best Bridge-Building: John Dehlin’s podcast interviews. If you need just one, I nominate the interview with Bill Bradshaw, especially segment 4 on homosexuality.
Best New Blog: Invictus Pilgrim
Best Book Review:
The Defense of Fawn Brodie
Best Philosophical/Religious Post:
Correlation: An Uncorrelated History, in 9 parts
For best new blog:
http://cognitivedissenter.com/
Best new blog:
http://www.mbnalively.blogspot.com
I nominate http://packham.n4m.org/temples.htm for best humorous post. (Yes, I know it’s simply recounting exactly what happens in temple ceremonies, so the humor is unintentional…)
Best Science Post – USU Shaft This is your brain on God http://usu-shaft.com/2010/this-is-your-brain-on-god/
Best Science – Life as a Reader, Crucial Facts on MGM http://lifeofcarla.blogspot.com/2010/09/mgm-infant-circumcision.html
Best Science – Life as a Reader, What You Need to Know about Hospital and Home Birth in America http://lifeofcarla.blogspot.com/2010/09/home-birth-why-i-think-its-awesome.html
Best Exit Story – The Iron Rod How I Became a Formon http://the-iron-rod.blogspot.com/2010/09/how-i-became-formon.html
Best individual video – It’s a long shot anybody else remembers this, but there was a girl who did a cartoon-style “I’m a Mormon” video where she talked about believing in equality for LGBT people.
Most Humorous Post – Ward Gossip Less Active Learns Morality from Kitten http://wardgossip.blogspot.com/2010/10/less-active-learns-morality-from-kitten.html
Most Humorous Post – the loathesome joy To the straight guy at the party last night http://jcfitzner.tumblr.com/post/835175821/to-the-straight-guy-at-the-party-last-night
Best Political Post – The Narrow Gate, The TSA and the Constitutional Right to Travel http://thecjshow.blogspot.com/2010/12/tsa-and-constitutional-right-to-travel.html
Best Book Review – Life as a Reader, Jesus Interrupted Book Review http://lifeofcarla.blogspot.com/2010/09/jesus-interrupted-book-review.html
Best LDS Interest Podcast – Mormon Expression Podcast http://mormonexpression.com/
Best Philosophical/Religious Post – Molly Muses, Levels of Comprehension http://mollymuses.wordpress.com/2010/10/01/levels-of-comprehension/
Best Philo/Relig Post – Life as a Reader, I am a Cafeteria Catholic http://lifeofcarla.blogspot.com/2010/11/i-am-cafeteria-catholic.html
Best New Blog – Poly Mom http://polyamorymom.blogspot.com/
Best Science Post – USU Shaft This is your brain on God http://usu-shaft.com/2010/this-is-your-brain-on-god/
Best Science – Life as a Reader, Crucial Facts on MGM http://lifeofcarla.blogspot.com/2010/09/mgm-infant-circumcision.html
Best Science – Life as a Reader, What You Need to Know about Hospital and Home Birth in America http://lifeofcarla.blogspot.com/2010/09/home-birth-why-i-think-its-awesome.html
Best Exit Story – The Iron Rod How I Became a Formon http://the-iron-rod.blogspot.com/2010/09/how-i-became-formon.html
Best individual video – It’s a long shot anybody else remembers this, but there was a girl who did a cartoon-style “I’m a Mormon” video where she talked about believing in equality for LGBT people.
Most Humorous Post – Ward Gossip Less Active Learns Morality from Kitten http://wardgossip.blogspot.com/2010/10/less-active-learns-morality-from-kitten.html
Most Humorous Post – the loathesome joy To the straight guy at the party last night http://jcfitzner.tumblr.com/post/835175821/to-the-straight-guy-at-the-party-last-night
Best Political Post – The Narrow Gate, The TSA and the Constitutional Right to Travel http://thecjshow.blogspot.com/2010/12/tsa-and-constitutional-right-to-travel.html
Best Book Review – Life as a Reader, Jesus Interrupted Book Review http://lifeofcarla.blogspot.com/2010/09/jesus-interrupted-book-review.html
Best LDS Interest Podcast – Mormon Expression Podcast http://mormonexpression.com/
Best Philosophical/Religious Post – Molly Muses, Levels of Comprehension http://mollymuses.wordpress.com/2010/10/01/levels-of-comprehension/
Best Philo/Relig Post – Life as a Reader, I am a Cafeteria Catholic http://lifeofcarla.blogspot.com/2010/11/i-am-cafeteria-catholic.html
Best New Blog – Poly Mom http://polyamorymom.blogspot.com/
Best Gender/Orientation Post – The Narrow Gate If Homosexuality is OK, Why Is Incest Wrong? http://thecjshow.blogspot.com/2010/12/if-homosexuality-is-ok-why-is-incest.html
Best YouTube Channel: http://www.youtube.com/user/iamanexmormon
Best Book Review: Eliza R. Snitch’s multipart series on Women Who Run With Wolves
http://elizasnitch.com/recovery/why-im-growing-out-my-claws/
http://elizasnitch.com/recovery/instinct-and-the-spirit-are-not-the-same/
http://elizasnitch.com/recovery/dem-bones/
http://elizasnitch.com/recovery/gordon/
http://elizasnitch.com/blasphemy/devilish-dreams/
OK, just fished everyone’s nominations out of the filer. Sorry for that!
Here’s a category suggestion: best DAMU internet handle
And here’s my nomination: Me_MyZelph_And_I
Great ideas!!!
BTW, as Andrew notes, these sorts of link-full comments have a tendency to fall into the spam filter, especially if you haven’t posted comments here before.
If you post a nomination and it falls into the spam filter, please email me chanson dot exmormon at gmail dot com so that I will know to fish it out — thanks!
I nominate this post for Best Comment by a Former Megachurch Pastor:
http://usu-shaft.com/2010/my-apology-to-pastor-ted-haggard/
Ha ha, thanks Chino. That’s at least one category that SHAFT will win.
I just noticed Andrew S’s new post/link above and so maybe this is a good time to mention that I completely agree with the MSP governing board’s decision to limit the Brodie Awards to recognizing excellence in exmo blogging.
Snarky tongue-in-cheek “prizes” for over-the-top bloggernacle posts will be awarded in a separate contest that’s being organized by the r/exmormon bunch. If you’d like to help them decide on a name for this latest bit of exmo silliness, please click here. Cheers.
Chino — Thanks!
I hope nobody objects, but we’d like everyone to aspire to win a Brodie — not have people wondering whether it’s a good thing or a booby prize. Thus the Reddit exmos will be hosting the awards for the best of the you-can-hardly-believe-it’s-real earnest LDS folly. Please join in the fun and add your suggestions here!!
I just noticed PostMormon has a thread listing recommended static sites, so I’m stealing their recommendations and posting them here as my nominations for Best Static Site on LDS Issues:
wivesofjosephsmith.org
realmormonhistory.com
mormoncurtain.com
mormonthink.com
lds-mormon.com
20truths.info
utlm.org
i4m.com
And I want to add my nomination for best faithful blog:
Times and Seasons
Best LDS Church Watch:
Joanna Brooks @ Religion Dispatches
Jana Riess @ BeliefNet
Best Comic/Graphic/LOLDamuz:
Mormon comic submitted to FFFFUUUUUUUUUUU really hits home.
Mormon Fakebook Update: 1
LOLDamuz: Let Him Enter
Best Individual Video:
Hi, My name is Rock, and yep, I’m a Mormon
“Hi, my name is Robert and I’m an Ex Mormon.”
Examining Holland’s Talk (1 of 5)
I would like to shamelessly plug the site I put on the internet this last year:
http://www.ldsorigins.com/
What I think I add to the table is the amount of references I include at the bottom of each history page, plus my interview with an LDS apostle and church historian.
I’m not sure what category it might fit in…perhaps if there was a Best New Information/History Site category.
I also would like to nominate LDS Origins – I thoroughly enjoyed the writing style and the interviews were most interesting and certainly a different approach.
Then I found “How I became a Formon” sincere and to the point.
As to which categories they fit in I am not sure. Tx
I would like to nominate Ward Gossip for best humor site.
http://wardgossip.blogspot.com/
I second the nomination for http://mbnalively.blogspot.com/ as best new blog!